Nonprofit AF

What the heck is the Overton Window, and how can we use it to advance progressive goals?

Posted on May 12, 2025May 12, 2025 by Vu

[A grey, white, and orange kitten, standing at a window, staring outside. Image by g3gg0 on Pixabay]

Hi everyone, before we get started, our friends at the National Council of Nonprofits are sounding the alarm about the Republicans’ proposed tax bill, which the hope to pass by summer. If it passes, it will be very bad for our sector and the people we serve. It includes allowing authority for Trump and his minions to revoke nonprofit status from any organization it doesn’t like, expand taxes on private foundations to make up for tax cuts on the corporations and wealthy individuals, cut funding for Medicaid and SNAP, among other horrible things. Please see CNC’s website for more information and actions we need to be taking. Let’s get ready for this battle.

***

Over the past few months, you’ve probably heard the term Overton Window being tossed around. It’s a term coined by Joseph P. Overton, senior VP of the conservative think tank the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. I recommend this really great 7-minute clip on it, but basically it’s the range of ideas and policies that are politically acceptable to the general population at any given time. For instance, a few decades ago, marriage equality was unthinkable, and even popular Democratic presidents still opposed it. Now, the Window has widened to include LGBTQ rights so it’s not too controversial for politicians, even conservative ones, to say they support it.

I’m bringing it up because the right-wing, under Trump, has been masterful at shifting this Window on a variety of issues, to terrifying results. They propose a steady stream of abhorrent ideas, which then makes less loathsome ones seem reasonable by comparison. For instance, when they talk about sending US citizens to concentration camps in El Salvador without due process, it trains the public to think that sending non-US citizens to these camps without due process less horrifying in comparison (when it absolutely is still very horrifying).

It’s time for progressives to be arrogant, messy, and unapologetic

Posted on May 5, 2025May 6, 2025 by Vu

[Image description: A hyena, which looks kind of like a dog, with golden fur, staring at the camera. This image has nothing to do with the post, except that I think this hyena, using random chance to make decisions, would be more qualified than most of our executive branch. Image by tommileew on Pixabay]

There’s been various articles written on the phenomenon of Imposter Syndrome, such as this one by Ruchika Tulshyan and Jodi-Ann Burey called “Stop Telling Women They Have Imposter Syndrome” and this one by our colleague Esther Saehyun Lee, titled “You’re not feeling imposter syndrome, you are an imposter: Identity and belonging in nonprofit work.”

I’m glad to see the pushback against the concept of Imposter Syndrome, since it often places the burdens on individuals who are often already marginalized to examine themselves and change their behavior, instead of forcing systems to stop being so inequitable.

Foundation trustees, help save democracy or get out of the way

Posted on April 29, 2025April 29, 2025 by Vu

[Image description: A light-grey bird, standing on a wire, looking to the left with a rather serious expression. Image by balouriarajesh at Pixabay]

Hi everyone, I’m thinking of all my friends and colleagues in Canada, who just achieved a resounding election victory against their version of MAGA; this came after the horrific tragedy over the weekend at the Lapu Lapu Day Festival.

Last week, I gave a keynote at a conference of funders who were mostly awesome and fired up to advance DEI and fight to save democracy. During the Q&A, however, a program officer asked, “How do we make change happen when the people with all the power at our foundations are not in the room?”

By that, of course, he meant foundation board members, aka trustees. This is a dynamic we see across the sector: Foundation staff who get it, who want to do things differently and better, and who leave these gatherings inspired only to be quickly demoralized when they go back to their workplaces and must deal with their foundation trustees, who are often the biggest barriers to progress in our field.

Foundation trustees, if you are reading this, thank you; just the fact that these words somehow reached you is a miracle, as we don’t ever see or hear from many of you. Right now, everything is on fire as the right-wing dismantles every institution keeping democracy and society intact. Nonprofits and foundation are trying to work together to fight this authoritarian regime. You play a vital role. But for you to be effective in that role, there are a few things we need you to understand. These are things your program officers want to tell you but usually can’t due to power dynamics:

A mass uprising is needed. Our sector has a vital role to play.

Posted on April 21, 2025April 29, 2025 by Vu

[Image description: An outline of a clenched fist, sprayed in black paint on a brick wall. Image by TheDigitalArtist on Pixabay]

I know everyone has been on edge, anticipating the Executive Orders that are coming this week, possibly even today, that are targeted to devastate the nonprofit sector, including targeting climate-focused organizations, punishing organizations that fund or do work abroad, revoking the tax status of organizations like Harvard that refuse to comply with the administration’s ideology, and designating certain organizations as terrorist organizations.

The attacks are strategic, designed to overwhelm and exhaust us all so we can’t fight back against the horrible things this fascist administration is doing, including the planned gutting of Head Start, a vital resource for hundreds of thousands of low-income families.

The actions of this administration are unlawful, as this helpful document from the National Council of Nonprofits shows. It has no authority to limit what types of orgs are eligible for 501c3 status, nor does the president have authority to order the IRS to revoke the c3 status of specific nonprofits, nor does the IRS have the authority to remove nonprofits of its status without due process.

Of course, none of that matters when we’re dealing with a dictator, one who has suggested deporting US citizens to torture camps abroad and who has ignored even the unanimous ruling of the Supreme Court.

Funders, here’s the blueprint for saving democracy

Posted on April 14, 2025April 15, 2025 by Vu

[Image description: A protestor in front of a tent, surrounded by several signs. One that stands out says “Stay the course, this will happen to YOU” accompanied by several pictures of war and suffering. Image by greyerbaby on Pixabay]

Two weeks ago, I met with a colleague who was invited to a convening of funders in Seattle. He reported that the funders present were wringing their hands, unsure of what their foundations should be doing to respond to the rapid dismantling of democracy and the exponential increase in suffering communities are facing.

This week, David Callahan of Inside Philanthropy wrote a post on LinkedIn reporting similar dynamics of tentativeness among funders across the sector. David suggests several possible reasons for the hesitation, including shellshock from the cruelty and chaos unleashed by this administration, as well as funders’ lack of knowledge and confidence as to what strategies would work to counter it. While David and I agree on a lot of things, it’s this last point he makes where we may differ in opinions:

“Third, there’s only so much that funders can or should do to lead. Philanthropy’s main role is to support civil society groups, who rightly should be out front in the pushback to Trump’s actions. If those organizations aren’t coalescing around a set of promising big strategies — and there’s no sign they are — funders have limited options. They can’t bankroll grand new plans to fight MAGA if such plans don’t yet exist.

“Or, as one foundation CEO told me, ‘People keep yelling at us to give out more money, but for what?’”